Start with all four dedicated Egg Hunt Moments. Completing these gives you the Orange Egg and 10 program points. Combined with the points from finishing the moments themselves, you’ll reach 20 points total right off the bat. These early points set a strong foundation for the rest of the hunt.
Reward:
Orange Egg (10 points)
10 program points for completing Moments
Step 2: Stack Your Lineup for Conquest (30–40 Points)
Next, enter the Egg Map Conquest. To get the Blue and Yellow Eggs, capture all territories and strongholds while completing multiple Mystery Missions at once. Building your lineup strategically is essential here. Use players who match the Mystery Mission requirements to save time and knock out several objectives in one game.
Mission Clue Required Action Mode Recommended Players
Wait a Third… Win a game Any Gold Clay Holmes (Yankees Team Affinity)
I'm Blue Win a game Any Kerry Wood
Conq Mysterymaxxing XBH Conquest Troy Tulowitzki
Whoops… Pitch 1 inning Any A.J. Puk
Back series XBH Any Nolan Arenado, Nolan Gorman, Juan Yepez, Dylan Carlson
This approach usually takes 20–30 minutes and can push you toward the 50–60 point mark fast.
Step 3: Diamond Quest & Mini Seasons (Final Points)
If you haven’t reached 100 points yet, use Diamond Quest and Mini Seasons to finish off the program.
Diamond Quest: Complete the map to earn the Pink and Purple Eggs.
KYLE TEST: Hit a home run with any player named Kyle (like Kyle Schwarber) in Stadium Challenge or Showdown.
Mini Seasons: Earn 500 PXP using players wearing #7 or #28 (e.g., Ivan Rodriguez, Adell, Biggio).
These missions are usually quick and can help you hit 100 points with minimal repetition.
Step 4: Bonus Online Eggs
For those who prefer online play or want to skip offline missions, two bonus eggs can add extra points:
Red Egg: 3 Stolen Bases in Multiplayer
Green Egg: 10 Doubles in Multiplayer
These are optional but worth pursuing if you want to secure maximum rewards without repeating offline content.
Notable Rewards
Completing the Egg Hunt earns valuable items that boost your Diamond Dynasty squad or career progression:
10 Points: 87 OVR Tyler Rogers
50 Points: 89 OVR Jason Varitek
90 Points: Candy Basket Deluxe Pack
100 Points: 90 OVR Jackson Merrill + 5,000 XP
If you want to power up your progress even faster, consider using safe MLB The Show 26 stubs for sale from U4N, a trusted platform used by competitive players to skip the boring grind and focus on practicing. This can help you fill your lineup with elite players quickly, making the Egg Hunt even easier to complete.
Following this strategy, you can finish the MLB The Show 26 Egg Hunt in just a few hours while maximizing rewards and efficiency. Focus on Moments first, stack your lineup wisely, and take advantage of online bonus missions to collect every egg fast.